Tuesday, May 22, 2012

Democracy the Labour way


It seems that Labour’s bully boy tactics have come to the fore once again in RCT.  Not content with holding 60 out of 75 seats on the Council they appear to want to quash any attempts by others to hold them to account.

Following the May 3rd election talks were held between Mike Powell, Welsh Liberal Democrat Councillor for Trallwn, the sole Conservative Councillor, and the newly elected Independent Councillors regarding forming a group.

An agreement was reached with Cllr James, Conservative, and two of the Independent Councillors to do just that.  The group, to be called the Democratic Alliance Group, would have been a loose alliance formed merely to enable members to take advantage of the scrutiny system.  There would have been no obligation for them to vote in the same way, and no party political influence brought to bear on Independent members.

Unless a Councillor is a member of a group then he / she gets no seats on any of the scrutiny committees which are supposed to hold the administration to account and give at least some outward semblance of democracy.

It seems that the Labour group want to stamp out even this low level of opposition.  Word was allegedly spread by the Labour councillor for Ferndale that the Independent member also representing this ward was in effect selling out to the electorate by joining forces with the Welsh Liberal Democrats and the Tories.

Being new to the political hot bed that is RCT and the dirty tricks of the Labour party, the Councillor reacted in just the way Labour wanted him to, and pulled out of the group.

This now means that he will be operating completely on  his own in the Chamber and elsewhere, with no experienced Councillors to look to for advice.  He will not be able to sit on any of the scrutiny committees.  He is isolated.

Strangely enough the Labour party did not concern themselves with the Independence of mind of Independent members prior to this.  They had no concerns about it when they appointed Roger Turner Chair of the Overview & Scrutiny committee, even though he was a member of a group.  Of course Mr Turner later joined the Labour party having been rewarded sufficiently by them with his special responsibility allowance for several years.  He was allowed to hold on to that extra payment when the ruling group decided they no longer needed anyone independent to Chair it.
Democracy – it is a word the Labour party need to familiarize themselves with.

6 comments:

Anonymous said...

Cllr Howe of Ferndale has not been bullied into refusing to join the Democratic Alliance Group. The Labour Party were making smears against Phillip Howe well before, during and since the election, he is not 'bullied'. He is made of sterner stuff. He decided that it would be inappropriate to join an alliance with LibDems and Tories on the basis of his own political viewpoint. He has also been in discussions with the Plaid group on various issues of importance. Obviously he can apply to join Plaid and play a role in the group if he chooses to, or remain a true independent. It is insulting to suggest that he is a councillor that can be bullied, although it is very true that Labour try to.

DutchEnery said...

Damn it, no change at all then? Even when Russell Roberts bit the dust things have not really changed? Then we will have to ensure more Labour councillors say goodbye.

DutchEnery said...

Damn it, no change at all then? Even when Russell Roberts bit the dust things have not really changed? Then we will have to ensure more Labour councillors say goodbye.

Nick Powell said...

While I agree that the system is corrupt & every cllr should be on at least one scrutiny committee i wouldn't agree with joining the Lib tory group

DutchEnery said...

Wrong cologne perhaps?

Anonymous said...

Rather arrogant don't you think "we will have to ensure that more Labour councillors say goodbye" and replace them who? someone like you? Perhaps when Mike Powell moves to France (where he spends most of his time anyway)you could go with him. See how you would both fare politically in France. The Lib Dems certainly have no credibility in Britain!!!!